26 December 2011

2011 Awards

I have decided to give a few awards this year to highlight those whose work I find stimulating, eye-opening or essential. Feel free to submit your own nominations in the comments.

Best Book I Read in 2011

The Hungry World, by Nick Cullather, was actually published in 2010, but I did not get to it until this year. The book tells the complex story of the inter-relationship of US Cold War politics and the so-called Green Revolution in Asia.

It is not an easy book, and it does not have a simple linear narrative. But it is chock full of original historical research, skews multiple myths and provides an insightful look into how technology, politics and culture intersect at the level of global geo-politics.

This book has provoked a lot of thinking on my part this year and has influenced my ongoing research trajectory more than any other.

Best Institutional Blog

The Lowy Interpreter is a blog run by The Lowy Institute for International Policy, which is located in Sydney, Australia.  The blog describes its perspective as follows:
We seek a global audience, but our perspective is Australian. Like the Institute itself, The Interpreter has a strong commitment to analytic integrity. Its editorial stance is independent, non-partisan and directed towards informing and deepening the debate about international policy.
They succeed admirably in that ambition, making it a daily stop for me.

Best Group Blog

Actually, I don't even know if VoxEu qualifies as a blog -- they call themselves a "policy portal." Whatever it is, VoxEu has, word for word, one of the best one-stop-shops for high quality and provocative policy analysis anywhere on the web.

A project of the Centre for Economic Policy Research, VoxEu seeks to:
. . . promote research-based policy analysis and commentary by leading scholars. The intended audience is economists in governments, international organisations, academia and the private sector as well as journalists specializing in economics, finance and business.
Every day I find something new, interesting, challenging or unexpected on their homepage, and it never seems to stop, making it another daily read for me. In fact, in just a few minutes I'll be blogging on a fascinating piece I found there just today.

Best Individual Blog 
I don't know where he gets the energy or the patience, but Andy Revkin's Dot Earth at the New York Times is an institution in media coverage and commentary on the environment and climate change in particular. Over the years, Revkin has taken heat from just about everyone in the climate debate -- me included;-) -- and he has continued to produce daily (and sometimes hourly) content that can be found nowhere else. Revkin's email chains are legendary and are a key tool to get experts talking among one another, which serves his blogging but also the community itself. Revkin has moved slowly but steadily toward asserting his own voice, which I hope continues. For me, 2012 will see a dramatic turn away from climate as I devote most of my time to a new book, but DotEarth will be one key way that I'll keep touch.

Congrats to all the winners! ;-)

10 comments:

Roberto Berlinck said...

Hi Roger,

Thanks for the suggestions. I did very much like the VoxEu post "Oil and democracy: New insights". This post has many relationships with some of the current Brazilian politics facts. Such as, for example, a very subtle project on "media subject control", which started not much later when the pre-salt oil reserves have been discovered. Just a coincidence?

All the best,
Roberto

Jonathan said...

"For me, 2012 will see a dramatic turn away from climate"

I seem to recall you saying that last year?

Roger Pielke, Jr. said...

-2-Jonathan

Maybe so, but with TCF coming out 11/2010 and the paperback 12/2011 that was never going to happen ;-)

Carrick said...

You should have given yourself an award for TCF---just to vex your critics. That would have been priceless to watch.

HowardW said...

How about an award for the worst published (peer-reviewed) article on climate?

TheTracker said...

"How about an award for the worst published (peer-reviewed) article on climate?"

Come on. There's no competition there. It's Roy by a mile. How many articles are so awful they actually cause the editor of the journal to resign in disgrace?

Sharon F. said...

OK, so inquiring minds are interested in the topic of your new book/interests..

Happy New Year to all!

marci_b said...

The Hungry World is a great book! It has definitely had an influence on my dissertation research. Can't wait to see what you're up to next!

c1ue said...

VoxEU would be a lot more credible if their EU bias wasn't so very blatant, and the resulting skew to their analysis not so pronounced.

An otherwise seemingly well researched and articulate blog is thus undermined by its multifarious and ongoing failures to actually be right. A few areas which highlight this:

1) PIIGS and the Euro train wreck. Consistently underplayed with little or no mention of Italy as the true driver (as opposed to the nasty Greeks and Portuguese)

2) Ongoing and repeatedly wrong pronouncements of short term doom in the United States

Jonathan said...

Returning to your "dramatic turn away from climate" I'm intrigued to see that you seem to agree with James Delingpole on something.

Post a Comment